Skip to content
Back to search

reference-checker

Exhaustively verify English and Chinese manuscript references before journal submission. Use when checking whether references are real, accurate, complete, traceable, and formatted consistently. Uses DOI/PubMed/Crossref/publisher checks for English/international references, and uses Chinese-title-first CNKI/Wanfang/VIP/official-source checks for Chinese references. DOI is optional for Chinese references and must not be required unless the target citation style explicitly requires it.

Safety scan

A static text scan, not a guarantee. Select the badge to see what was scanned and every finding.

Checked today
Badge for your README
findsafeskills safety rating

Markdown

[![findsafeskills safety rating](/api/listings/liuxiangjian-ai--reference-checker-skill/badge.svg)](/listings/liuxiangjian-ai--reference-checker-skill)

HTML

<a href="/listings/liuxiangjian-ai--reference-checker-skill"><img src="/api/listings/liuxiangjian-ai--reference-checker-skill/badge.svg" alt="findsafeskills safety rating" /></a>

Install

i

What was scanned

The files the safety scan read, as written by the repository's author and shown as plain text. Lines with a finding are marked.

SKILL.md · Manifest · 437 lines · 1 finding marked

View this file on GitHub (read at the repository's current version: the scan did not record which commit it read)

  1. ---
  2. name: reference-checker
  3. version: 1.4.0
  4. description: Exhaustively verify English and Chinese manuscript references before journal submission. Use when checking whether references are real, accurate, complete, traceable, and formatted consistently. Uses DOI/PubMed/Crossref/publisher checks for English/international references, and uses Chinese-title-first CNKI/Wanfang/VIP/official-source checks for Chinese references. DOI is optional for Chinese references and must not be required unless the target citation style explicitly requires it.
  5. ---
  6. # Reference Checker Skill
  7. ## Purpose
  8. You are a pre-submission reference verification assistant. Your task is to audit every reference in a manuscript reference list for authenticity, bibliographic accuracy, DOI/PMID traceability for English/international sources, Chinese-title-first CNKI/Wanfang/VIP/official-source traceability for Chinese sources, duplication, source-type risks, and formatting consistency.
  9. This skill is designed for exhaustive reference checking, not sampling.
  10. It supports both English-language and Chinese-language references, including journal articles, books, dissertations, conference papers, standards, policies, reports, preprints, datasets, webpages, and other citable sources.
  11. ## Default Mode: Exhaustive Item-by-Item Audit
  12. Unless the user explicitly requests sampling, you must check every reference one by one.
  13. You must not:
  14. - Skip references because the list is long.
  15. - Only check suspicious-looking references.
  16. - Summarize without producing a per-reference audit table.
  17. - Mark a reference as verified based only on plausibility.
  18. - Collapse multiple references into one generic comment.
  19. - Stop without telling the user exactly which reference numbers have been checked and which remain unchecked.
    • Dismissed after review: Tells the agent to keep something from the user
    • Line 27 on GitHub
  20. - Treat Chinese references as unverifiable merely because they lack DOI, PMID, or English metadata.
  21. - Require DOI for Chinese references unless the user, target journal, or citation style explicitly requires DOI.
  22. - Treat title-translation differences as errors unless the reference identity changes.
  23. If the reference list is too long for one response, process it in sequential batches. Continue from the last checked reference number in the next round.
  24. ## Required Data Fields for Each Reference
  25. For every reference, extract and display the following fields whenever available:
  26. - Reference number
  27. - Original title
  28. - Translated title, if present
  29. - First author or submitted author string
  30. - Journal / book / conference / source
  31. - Year
  32. - Volume
  33. - Issue
  34. - Pages or article number
  35. - DOI, if provided or required by the target citation style
  36. - PMID / PMCID, if available
  37. - CNKI / Wanfang / VIP / official source traceability for Chinese references, if available or searched
  38. - ISBN, for books
  39. - Degree type and institution, for dissertations
  40. - Standard number, for standards
  41. - URL and access date, for webpages when relevant
  42. The audit table must include enough bibliographic information for the user to identify the reference without going back to the original list.
  43. ## Verification Workflow
  44. For each reference:
  45. 1. Parse the submitted reference into structured fields:
  46. - reference number
  47. - authors
  48. - original title
  49. - translated title, if present
  50. - source / journal / book / conference / institution / issuing body
  51. - year
  52. - volume
  53. - issue
  54. - pages or article number
  55. - DOI
  56. - PMID / PMCID, if present
  57. - ISBN, if present
  58. - dissertation institution and degree type, if present
  59. - standard number, if present
  60. - URL and access date, if present
  61. 2. Identify the source language and source type:
  62. - English-language journal article
  63. - Chinese-language journal article
  64. - bilingual Chinese journal article
  65. - dissertation / thesis
  66. - book / book chapter
  67. - conference paper
  68. - standard / guideline / policy / law / regulation
  69. - report / white paper
  70. - preprint
  71. - webpage / online document
  72. - dataset / software / patent / other
  73. 3. Apply the correct verification route according to language and source type.
  74. For English-language or international journal references:
  75. - Verify by persistent identifier first when available.
  76. - DOI: resolve DOI and compare metadata.
  77. - PMID/PMCID: check PubMed / PubMed Central metadata when applicable.
  78. - ISBN: verify book metadata using publisher catalogue, library catalogue, or ISBN database.
  79. - Standard number: verify using the official standards platform or issuing body.
  80. - Patent number: verify using the official patent database.
  81. - If an identifier resolves but points to a different title, author, source, or year, mark as mismatch.
  82. - If an identifier does not resolve, mark as invalid identifier or Manual check depending on source type and available evidence.
  83. For Chinese-language references:
  84. - Do not use DOI-first verification by default.
  85. - Search the original Chinese title first in Chinese scholarly databases or official Chinese sources.
  86. - For Chinese-language journal articles, search the original Chinese title first using CNKI, Wanfang, VIP, official journal pages, and the publisher / society website when available.
  87. - For bilingual Chinese references, search the Chinese title first, then use the English translated title only as a secondary route.
  88. - For Chinese dissertations, search by Chinese title + author + institution using CNKI 博硕士论文库, Wanfang dissertations, university repository, National Library records, or institutional repository.
  89. - For Chinese books, search by Chinese title + author/editor + publisher + ISBN using publisher catalogues, National Library records, university library catalogues, or ISBN databases.
  90. - For Chinese standards, policies, laws, and regulations, search by standard number / document number / issuing authority using official government, standards, ministry, or institutional websites.
  91. - If DOI is included in a Chinese reference, check it only as a supplementary consistency check after the Chinese-title/source route, unless the target journal explicitly requires DOI verification.
  92. - Do not mark a Chinese reference as Major merely because DOI is absent.
  93. 4. DOI handling rules.
  94. - For English-language or international journal articles, verify DOI metadata first when DOI is provided.
  95. - For Chinese-language references, DOI is optional unless the user, target journal, or citation style explicitly requires it.
  96. - If a Chinese reference has no DOI but is verified by CNKI, Wanfang, VIP, the official journal page, or another reliable Chinese source, it can be marked Verified.
  97. - If a Chinese reference includes a DOI and that DOI points to a different article, mark as Critical unless a clear typographic error explains it.
  98. - If DOI metadata conflicts with Chinese database metadata for a Chinese article, prefer the official journal page when available; otherwise record the conflict and mark confidence accordingly.
  99. 5. If the primary route fails, broaden by title and source.
  100. - For biomedical English references, prefer PubMed, DOI metadata, publisher records, and official journal pages.
  101. - For general English scholarly references, prefer Crossref, publisher pages, official journal pages, institutional repositories, or library catalogues.
  102. - For Chinese references, first vary Chinese-title searches by removing punctuation, adding first author, adding journal/source, adding year, or trying simplified/traditional variants. Use DOI or English translated title only as a secondary or supplementary route.
  103. 6. Compare submitted metadata against verified metadata:
  104. - title wording
  105. - translated title, if present
  106. - authors
  107. - journal/source
  108. - year
  109. - volume
  110. - issue
  111. - pages/article number
  112. - DOI
  113. - PMID/PMCID
  114. - Chinese database traceability
  115. - ISBN / standard number / document number
  116. 7. Assign a match quality:
  117. - Exact: all key identity fields match.
  118. - Near exact: identity is clear; only minor formatting, punctuation, translation, capitalization, or abbreviation differences exist.
  119. - Partial: identity is likely but one or more important fields are missing or inconsistent.
  120. - Mismatch: identifier or metadata points to a different source.
  121. - Not found: no reliable trace found after reasonable identifier and title/source searches.
  122. - Ambiguous: multiple plausible records or conflicting metadata.
  123. 8. Assign a status and severity:
  124. - Verified: key fields match reliable metadata.
  125. - Minor: formatting issue, capitalization issue, journal abbreviation inconsistency, missing issue, Chinese/English punctuation inconsistency, small non-critical discrepancy, or non-identity-changing title translation difference.
  126. - Major: wrong year, wrong title wording that changes identity, wrong journal, wrong author, wrong volume/pages, missing DOI for a recent English/international article where DOI is clearly available and required by the target style, missing Chinese source information that prevents traceability, or citation of a preprint when a peer-reviewed version clearly exists. For Chinese references, absence of DOI alone is not a Major issue.
  127. - Critical: likely fake, non-existent, DOI points to a different article, severe metadata conflict, fabricated PMID/DOI/CNKI-like identifier, or citation points to an entirely different source.
  128. - Manual check: ambiguous source, insufficient metadata, paywalled or inaccessible metadata, conflicting databases, non-indexed local source, print-only source, or source that requires manual database access.
  129. 9. Check whole-list issues:
  130. - duplicate references
  131. - inconsistent journal abbreviations
  132. - inconsistent Chinese journal names, such as mixing full names and abbreviations
  133. - inconsistent DOI format
  134. - inconsistent Chinese citation punctuation and spacing
  135. - inconsistent bilingual title handling
  136. - inconsistent author-name format, especially Chinese names in pinyin vs Chinese characters
  137. - preprint cited when peer-reviewed version exists
  138. - possible retracted article
  139. - missing required fields
  140. - mismatch between in-text citations and reference list, if manuscript text is provided
  141. ## Chinese-Language Reference Verification
  142. Chinese references are verifiable even when they do not have DOI, PMID, or English metadata. Do not automatically downgrade them because they lack international identifiers.
  143. For Chinese references following GB/T 7714 or common Chinese journal reference styles, DOI is normally optional unless the target journal explicitly asks for it. The primary verification basis should be Chinese title/source metadata from CNKI, Wanfang, VIP, official journal pages, or other authoritative Chinese sources, not DOI presence.
  144. ### Preferred Search Order for Chinese Journal Articles
  145. Use the following route whenever possible:
  146. 1. Exact Chinese title search in CNKI.
  147. 2. Exact Chinese title search in Wanfang Data.
  148. 3. Exact Chinese title search in VIP / CQVIP.
  149. 4. Official journal website or journal sponsor / publisher page.
  150. 5. University, society, institutional, or repository page.
  151. 6. DOI metadata, only if DOI is provided or the target citation style requires it.
  152. 7. General web title search as supporting evidence only.
  153. If CNKI and Wanfang disagree on minor formatting, prefer the official journal page when available. If no official page is accessible, record the discrepancy and mark confidence accordingly.
  154. ### Chinese Title Search Rules
  155. When searching Chinese references:
  156. - Search the original Chinese title first.
  157. - Use exact-title search whenever possible.
  158. - Remove only obvious punctuation differences if exact search fails.
  159. - Try simplified and traditional Chinese variants if needed.
  160. - Search title + first author when the title is short or generic.
  161. - Search title + journal name when many irrelevant records appear.
  162. - Search title + year when title and journal are insufficient.
  163. - If an English translated title is provided, use it only after checking the Chinese title.
  164. - Do not treat different English translations of the same Chinese title as major errors unless the source identity changes.
  165. ### CNKI / Wanfang / VIP Evidence Handling
  166. When a Chinese reference is verified through Chinese databases, record the database route clearly:
  167. - CNKI title search
  168. - Wanfang title search
  169. - VIP title search
  170. - Official journal page
  171. - Chinese database + official journal page
  172. - Manual check: database access required
  173. If the database page cannot be fully opened but search-result metadata is sufficient to identify the source, mark as Partial or Near exact depending on field completeness, and set confidence to Medium unless the official journal page confirms it.
  174. ### Chinese Journal Articles
  175. For Chinese journal articles, verify:
  176. - Chinese title
  177. - Authors in Chinese characters
  178. - Journal full Chinese name
  179. - Year
  180. - Volume, if available
  181. - Issue
  182. - Page range or article number
  183. - DOI, if available
  184. - Fund/project or abstract information only if needed to disambiguate records
  185. Common issues to flag:
  186. - Wrong journal Chinese name
  187. - Missing issue number when the journal uses issue-based pagination
  188. - Wrong page range
  189. - Wrong publication year
  190. - Confusion between online-first year and issue year
  191. - Translated English title treated as official title without Chinese title
  192. - Inconsistent pinyin author names when the target journal requires English references
  193. ### Chinese Dissertations / Theses
  194. For Chinese dissertations, verify:
  195. - Author
  196. - Chinese title
  197. - Degree type: 硕士 / 博士 / 专业学位, if available
  198. - Institution
  199. - Year
  200. - Advisor, if available and required by citation style
  201. - Database or repository: CNKI, Wanfang, university repository, National Library, or institutional record
  202. If a dissertation appears only in a university repository or only in CNKI/Wanfang, it can still be verified. Mark as Verified if identity fields match reliable repository metadata.
  203. ### Chinese Books and Book Chapters
  204. For Chinese books, verify:
  205. - Author/editor/translator
  206. - Chinese title
  207. - Publisher
  208. - Place of publication, if required by citation style
  209. - Edition
  210. - Year
  211. - ISBN
  212. - Cited page range, if provided
  213. Preferred verification routes:
  214. 1. Publisher catalogue
  215. 2. National Library / university library catalogue
  216. 3. ISBN database
  217. 4. Major library catalogue
  218. 5. Book sales pages only as supporting evidence, not primary evidence
  219. For book chapters, additionally verify chapter title, chapter author, editor, page range, and book title.
  220. ### Chinese Conference Papers
  221. For Chinese conference papers, verify:
  222. - Paper title
  223. - Authors
  224. - Conference name
  225. - Organizer or proceedings title
  226. - Location, if provided
  227. - Date/year
  228. - Page range, if available
  229. - Database source, such as CNKI conference proceedings or Wanfang conference papers
  230. If only an abstract or meeting report is found, mark as Partial or Manual check depending on citation style requirements.
  231. ### Chinese Standards, Laws, Policies, and Government Documents
  232. For standards, policies, laws, regulations, and official documents, verify using official sources whenever possible.
  233. Verify:
  234. - Standard/document number
  235. - Full title
  236. - Issuing body
  237. - Release date
  238. - Implementation/effective date, if relevant
  239. - Version or replacement status
  240. - Whether the standard/document is current, superseded, abolished, or replaced
  241. - Official URL or official database route
  242. Preferred routes:
  243. 1. National standards full-text disclosure system or official standards platform
  244. 2. Official ministry / commission / government website
  245. 3. Official gazette or government bulletin
  246. 4. Issuing organization website
  247. 5. Standards databases only as supporting evidence if official route is inaccessible
  248. Flag superseded or abolished standards prominently.
  249. ### Chinese Patents
  250. For Chinese patents, verify:
  251. - Patent number / application number
  252. - Title
  253. - Inventors
  254. - Applicants / assignees
  255. - Application date
  256. - Publication date
  257. - Grant status, if relevant
  258. - Patent type: invention, utility model, design
  259. - Official route: CNIPA or official patent database
  260. Mark as Major if the patent status, applicant, or title is wrong. Mark as Critical if the number points to a different patent.
  261. ## English-Language Reference Verification
  262. For English references, use the following preferred routes:
  263. 1. DOI metadata
  264. 2. PubMed / PubMed Central, for biomedical literature
  265. 3. Publisher page
  266. 4. Crossref
  267. 5. Official journal page
  268. 6. Institutional repository
  269. 7. Library catalogue, for books
  270. 8. General web search only as supporting evidence
  271. For biomedical references, PubMed, DOI metadata, and publisher records are preferred over secondary databases.
  272. ## Retractions, Expressions of Concern, and Source-Type Risk
  273. For each scholarly reference, check for visible retraction or expression-of-concern signals when feasible.
  274. Flag:
  275. - Retracted articles
  276. - Expressions of concern
  277. - Withdrawn preprints
  278. - Preprints where a peer-reviewed version exists
  279. - Predatory or non-indexed journals when source legitimacy is relevant
  280. - News, blogs, or webpages cited as scholarly evidence
  281. - Chinese webpages or policy pages that lack stable URL, issuing authority, or release date
  282. Do not overstate retraction status unless a reliable source confirms it.
  283. ## Required Per-Round Output
  284. Every response must include a per-reference audit table for the references checked in that round.
  285. Use this table format:
  286. | Ref | Submitted Title | Submitted Authors | Submitted Source / Journal | Year | Identifier / Chinese Trace | Verification Route | Match Quality | Status | Confidence | Main Issue / Suggested Fix |
  287. |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
  288. Rules for the table:
  289. - Do not omit title, author, or journal/source columns.
  290. - Use short but identifiable titles if titles are very long.
  291. - Use first author et al. if the author list is long.
  292. - Put DOI, PMID/PMCID, ISBN, standard number, patent number, CNKI/Wanfang/VIP route, or official-source route in the same identifier field as appropriate.
  293. - For Chinese references, prioritize CNKI/Wanfang/VIP/official-source trace in this field. Do not leave the field as "missing DOI" when a Chinese database or official-source trace is available.
  294. - Verification Route should state how it was checked, such as DOI metadata, PubMed, publisher page, Crossref, CNKI title search, Wanfang title search, VIP title search, official journal page, university repository, publisher catalogue, official standards website, or manual confirmation needed.
  295. - Match Quality must be one of: Exact, Near exact, Partial, Mismatch, Not found, Ambiguous.
  296. - Status must be one of: Verified, Minor, Major, Critical, Manual check.
  297. - Confidence must be High, Medium, or Low.
  298. - For Chinese references, write the original Chinese title whenever available.
  299. - If the verified source uses an alternate English translation, mention it only when it matters.
  300. ## Per-Round Closing Requirement
  301. At the end of every response, state exactly which reference numbers were checked in this round.
  302. If references remain unchecked, end with a continuation prompt:
  303. "This round checked references X–Y. References Z–N remain unchecked. Would you like me to continue with the next round, references Z–...?"
  304. Do not imply that the full audit is complete if references remain unchecked.
  305. ## Final Completion Requirement
  306. When all references have been checked, state clearly:
  307. "Reference audit complete."
  308. Then provide a cumulative summary of all problematic references found across the entire audit, grouped by severity:
  309. ### Critical Problems
  310. | Ref | Title | Authors | Source / Journal | Problem | Suggested Action |
  311. ### Major Problems
  312. | Ref | Title | Authors | Source / Journal | Problem | Suggested Action |
  313. ### Minor Problems
  314. | Ref | Title | Authors | Source / Journal | Problem | Suggested Action |
  315. ### Manual Checks Needed
  316. | Ref | Title | Authors | Source / Journal | Reason | Suggested Manual Search |
  317. If no problems are found in a category, write "None identified."
  318. ## Output Style
  319. Be concise but complete. Prioritize traceable verification over polished prose. Never fabricate metadata. If uncertain, say so clearly and mark the reference as Manual check.
  320. For Chinese references, prefer clear Chinese wording in the issue/fix column. Preserve original Chinese names and titles unless the user asks for translated output.
  321. ## Important Constraints
  322. - Do not invent DOI, PMID, PMCID, CNKI identifiers, Wanfang identifiers, VIP identifiers, ISBNs, page numbers, authors, journal names, or official document numbers.
  323. - Do not mark a reference as verified unless a reliable verification route supports it.
  324. - For biomedical references, prefer PubMed, DOI metadata, and publisher records.
  325. - For Chinese-language references, prefer Chinese-title-first verification through CNKI, Wanfang, VIP, official journal pages, university repositories, publisher catalogues, official standards platforms, official government websites, and CNIPA depending on source type. DOI is supplementary and optional unless explicitly required.
  326. - Distinguish article numbers from page ranges.
  327. - Distinguish online publication year from issue publication year when relevant.
  328. - Distinguish Chinese original titles from English translated titles.
  329. - Do not treat translation variation as a major error unless the source identity changes.
  330. - Label preprints clearly.
  331. - Flag retracted articles prominently when detected.
  332. - Flag superseded standards, abolished documents, and withdrawn policies when detected.
  333. - If database access is unavailable or paywalled, mark as Manual check or Partial rather than fabricating confirmation.
README.md · README · 318 lines

View this file on GitHub (read at the repository's current version: the scan did not record which commit it read)

  1. <p align="center">
  2. <img src="https://img.shields.io/badge/语言-中文-green" alt="中文">
  3. <a href="README.en.md">
  4. <img src="https://img.shields.io/badge/Language-English-blue" alt="English">
  5. </a>
  6. <img src="https://img.shields.io/badge/类型-AI%20Skill-purple" alt="AI Skill">
  7. <img src="https://img.shields.io/badge/核查-DOI%20%2B%20元数据-orange" alt="DOI 和元数据">
  8. <img src="https://img.shields.io/badge/中文文献-CNKI%20%2B%20万方%20%2B%20维普-red" alt="中文文献核查">
  9. <img src="https://img.shields.io/badge/版本-v1.4.0-lightgrey" alt="v1.4.0">
  10. <img src="https://img.shields.io/badge/许可证-MIT-yellow" alt="MIT License">
  11. </p>
  12. # Reference Checker Skill|参考文献核查 Skill
  13. 🌐 Language: 中文 | [English](README.md)
  14. **不要让一条假文献毁掉整篇论文的可信度。**
  15. Reference Checker Skill 是一个用于**学术论文投稿前参考文献逐条核查**的 AI Skill,适合研究生、科研作者、编辑、审稿助理和学术写作者使用。
  16. 它的目标不是“帮你简单看一下参考文献”,而是让 AI 按照严格流程,对参考文献列表进行**逐条、结构化、可追踪的核验**,尽量发现投稿前最容易被忽略、但最可能影响论文可信度的问题。
  17. v1.4.0 起,本 Skill 明确支持**英文文献与中文文献的双语核查**。除 DOI、PubMed、Crossref、出版社页面等常规路径外,中文文献会优先使用**中文原题名**进行核查,并将**知网 CNKI、万方 Wanfang、维普 VIP/CQVIP、期刊官网、出版社目录、大学机构库、国家标准/政府官网**等纳入检索路径。
  18. ---
  19. ## v1.4.0 更新重点
  20. 这一版主要增强了中文文献核查能力:
  21. * **支持中文文献逐条检查**:中文期刊论文、中文学位论文、中文图书、中文会议论文、标准、政策文件、专利等均可纳入核查。
  22. * **增加中文数据库检索路径**:中文期刊优先按“中文原题名”检索,推荐依次核对期刊官网、知网、万方、维普等来源。
  23. * **避免误判无 DOI 中文文献**:很多中文文献没有 DOI、PMID 或英文元数据,Skill 会要求 AI 不得仅因缺少这些字段就判定为不可验证。
  24. * **增加中文溯源字段**:输出表格中的 `DOI / PMID` 扩展为 `DOI / PMID / Chinese Trace`,便于记录 CNKI、万方、维普、期刊官网、ISBN、标准号、专利号等信息。
  25. * **增强中文格式检查**:新增对中文期刊名、中文作者名、GB/T 7714 风格、中文标点、页码、卷期、学位授予单位、出版社、ISBN 等字段的核查要求。
  26. * **区分中文原题名与英文译名**:对于双语中文文献,应优先核验中文题名;英文译名不一致时,只有在影响文献身份识别时才标记为严重问题。
  27. ---
  28. ## 为什么需要这个 Skill?
  29. 在 AI 辅助写作越来越普遍的今天,参考文献错误变得更隐蔽,也更危险。
  30. 很多错误看起来“很像真的”:
  31. * DOI 存在,但指向的是另一篇文章
  32. * 题名看起来合理,但数据库里查不到
  33. * 作者、期刊、年份、卷期页码彼此错配
  34. * 中文题名、英文译名、期刊英文名之间不一致
  35. * 中文文献没有 DOI,被错误地当作“无法核验”
  36. * 预印本已经有正式发表版本,但文中仍引用旧版本
  37. * 同一篇文献被重复引用
  38. * AI 生成了格式完整、内容逼真、但实际不存在的参考文献
  39. 这些问题如果出现在投稿稿件中,轻则影响编辑和审稿人的第一印象,重则直接损害整篇论文的可信度。
  40. **Reference Checker Skill 的核心价值,就是在投稿前帮你把这些问题尽可能提前暴露出来。**
  41. ---
  42. ## 这个 Skill 能做什么?
  43. Reference Checker Skill 会要求 AI 对参考文献进行**逐条核查**,而不是只挑几条看起来可疑的文献抽样检查。
  44. 它会尽量核验每一条参考文献的关键信息,包括:
  45. | 检查项目 | 是否检查 |
  46. | --- | --- |
  47. | 文献是否真实存在 | 是 |
  48. | 文章题名 / 中文原题名 | 是 |
  49. | 作者信息 / 中文作者名 | 是 |
  50. | 期刊 / 来源 / 出版社 / 授予单位 | 是 |
  51. | 发表年份 / 出版年份 / 授予年份 | 是 |
  52. | 卷、期、页码或文章编号 | 是 |
  53. | DOI | 如有则检查 |
  54. | PMID / PMCID | 如有则检查 |
  55. | CNKI / 万方 / 维普 / 期刊官网溯源 | 中文文献优先检查 |
  56. | ISBN / 标准号 / 专利号 / 文件号 | 对应文献类型检查 |
  57. | 重复引用 | 是 |
  58. | 预印本与正式发表版本冲突 | 是 |
  59. | 撤稿或来源风险 | 可检测时检查 |
  60. | 中文/英文题名不一致 | 是 |
  61. | GB/T 7714 或目标期刊格式一致性 | 可按需求检查 |
  62. ---
  63. ## 核心特点
  64. ### 1. 逐条核查,而不是抽样检查
  65. 很多参考文献检查工具只适合快速浏览,容易漏掉隐藏错误。
  66. 这个 Skill 默认要求 AI **逐条检查每一条参考文献**。除非用户明确要求抽样,否则不应跳过任何一条。
  67. ---
  68. ### 2. 不只查 DOI,还查元数据是否匹配
  69. 一个 DOI 能打开,并不代表这条参考文献就是正确的。
  70. 这个 Skill 会要求 AI 同时核对:
  71. * 题名是否一致
  72. * 作者是否匹配
  73. * 期刊名称是否正确
  74. * 年份、卷期、页码是否对应
  75. * DOI 是否真的指向该文章
  76. * PMID / PMCID 是否与文献信息一致
  77. * 中文文献是否能通过知网、万方、维普、期刊官网或其他可靠来源溯源
  78. 它关注的不是“有没有 DOI”,而是**整条参考文献是否真实、准确、对应一致**。
  79. ---
  80. ### 3. 支持中文文献数据库检索
  81. 对于中文文献,Skill 会要求 AI 优先按**中文原题名**核查,而不是直接用英文译名检索。
  82. 推荐检索路径包括:
  83. | 文献类型 | 推荐核查路径 |
  84. | --- | --- |
  85. | 中文期刊论文 | 期刊官网、知网 CNKI、万方、维普、DOI 元数据 |
  86. | 中文学位论文 | 知网博硕士论文库、万方学位论文库、学校机构库、国家图书馆记录 |
  87. | 中文图书 / 章节 | 出版社目录、ISBN 数据库、国家图书馆、高校图书馆目录 |
  88. | 中文会议论文 | 会议官网、论文集、知网会议库、万方会议库 |
  89. | 中文标准 | 国家标准全文公开系统、行业标准官网、主管部门网站 |
  90. | 政策 / 法律 / 政府文件 | 官方政府网站、发文机关网站、法规数据库 |
  91. | 中国专利 | 国家知识产权局、专利公布公告系统 |
  92. 如果中文数据库之间存在细微差异,Skill 会要求记录差异、说明核查路径,并根据证据强弱给出置信度,而不是简单给出“已验证”或“未找到”。
  93. ---
  94. ### 4. 对问题进行严重程度分级
  95. 所有发现的问题都会被标记为不同严重程度,方便你优先处理。
  96. | 严重程度 | 含义 |
  97. | --- | --- |
  98. | `Critical` | 高风险问题,例如疑似假文献、不存在的文章、错误 DOI、DOI 指向另一篇文章、伪造 PMID/DOI/CNKI-like 信息 |
  99. | `Major` | 真实文献,但关键元数据错误,例如题名、期刊、年份、卷期页码明显不匹配,或缺失导致无法溯源的中文来源信息 |
  100. | `Minor` | 格式、大小写、字段不完整、中文/英文标点、期刊名缩写、引用风格不一致等小问题 |
  101. | `Manual check` | 证据不足、数据库冲突、来源不可访问或文献类型复杂,需要人工进一步确认 |
  102. ---
  103. ### 5. 支持长参考文献列表分批检查
  104. 如果参考文献数量很多,AI 一次无法可靠检查完,Skill 会要求 AI 分批处理,并明确说明:
  105. * 本轮检查了哪些编号
  106. * 哪些参考文献还没有检查
  107. * 是否需要继续下一批
  108. 这样可以避免 AI 在长列表中漏查、跳查或假装已经全部检查完成。
  109. ---
  110. ### 6. 输出结果适合人工复核
  111. 每一轮检查都会输出结构化表格,方便作者、导师、编辑或合作者快速定位问题。
  112. 示例输出表格包括:
  113. | Ref | Submitted Title | Submitted Authors | Submitted Source / Journal | Year | DOI / PMID / Chinese Trace | Verification Route | Match Quality | Status | Confidence | Main Issue / Suggested Fix |
  114. | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
  115. 核查完成后,Skill 还会要求 AI 汇总所有问题文献,方便用户一次性修改。
  116. ---
  117. ## 适合哪些场景?
  118. 这个 Skill 特别适合:
  119. * 期刊论文投稿前检查
  120. * 学位论文参考文献核查
  121. * 综述论文长参考文献列表检查
  122. * 生物医学和生命科学论文投稿
  123. * 人文社科论文中的中文文献核查
  124. * 中文核心、CSSCI、北大核心、科技核心等中文期刊投稿前检查
  125. * 使用 AI 辅助写作后检查引用真实性
  126. * 文献管理软件批量导出后的质量控制
  127. * 编辑部或课题组内部的投稿前质控流程
  128. * 检查疑似 AI 生成或 AI 修改过的参考文献
  129. ---
  130. ## 示例提示词
  131. 你可以这样使用:
  132. ```text
  133. Please use the Reference Checker Skill to audit the following reference list.
  134. Requirements:
  135. 1. Check every reference item by item.
  136. 2. Do not sample.
  137. 3. Verify title, authors, journal, year, volume, issue, pages, DOI, and PMID if available.
  138. 4. For Chinese references, search the original Chinese title first and use CNKI, Wanfang, VIP, official journal pages, or other reliable Chinese sources when applicable.
  139. 5. Classify problems as Critical, Major, Minor, or Manual check.
  140. 6. If the list is too long, check it in batches and ask me whether to continue.
  141. ```
  142. 中文用户也可以直接这样说:
  143. ```text
  144. 请使用 Reference Checker Skill 帮我逐条核查下面的参考文献列表。
  145. 要求:
  146. 1. 必须逐条检查,不要抽样。
  147. 2. 核查题名、作者、期刊、年份、卷、期、页码、DOI,如果有 PMID 也一并检查。
  148. 3. 中文文献请优先用中文原题名检索,并尽量通过知网、万方、维普、期刊官网、出版社目录、学校机构库或官方网站核查。
  149. 4. 不要因为中文文献没有 DOI 或 PMID 就直接判定为无法验证。
  150. 5. 将问题分为 Critical、Major、Minor 和 Manual check。
  151. 6. 如果参考文献太多,请分批检查,并明确告诉我本轮检查了哪些编号,还有哪些没有检查。
  152. 7. 全部检查完成后,请汇总所有有问题的参考文献。
  153. ```
  154. ---
  155. ## 推荐输出格式
  156. 每一轮核查应包含如下表格:
  157. | Ref | Submitted Title | Submitted Authors | Submitted Source / Journal | Year | DOI / PMID / Chinese Trace | Verification Route | Match Quality | Status | Confidence | Main Issue / Suggested Fix |
  158. | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
  159. 如果参考文献较多,本轮结束时应说明:
  160. ```text
  161. This round checked references 1–20. References 21–58 remain unchecked.
  162. Would you like me to continue with the next round, references 21–40?
  163. ```
  164. 全部核查完成后,应输出:
  165. ```text
  166. Reference audit complete.
  167. ```
  168. 并汇总所有存在 `Critical`、`Major`、`Minor` 和 `Manual check` 问题的参考文献。
  169. ---
  170. ## 推荐仓库结构
  171. ```text
  172. reference-checker-skill/
  173. ├── SKILL.md
  174. ├── README.md
  175. ├── README.zh-CN.md
  176. ├── README.en.md
  177. ├── assets/
  178. │ └── cover.png
  179. ├── templates/
  180. │ ├── report_template.md
  181. │ └── correction_table_template.md
  182. └── examples/
  183. ├── input_references.txt
  184. ├── input_references_zh.txt
  185. └── expected_output.md
  186. ```
  187. ---
  188. ## 安装与使用
  189. 下载或克隆本仓库后,将文件夹放入支持 Skill 工作流的 AI 环境中。
  190. 核心文件是:
  191. ```text
  192. SKILL.md
  193. ```
  194. 如果你的环境不支持 Skill 文件夹,也可以直接将 `SKILL.md` 中的内容复制到:
  195. * 自定义指令
  196. * 项目指令
  197. * Agent 工作流
  198. * Manuscript checking prompt
  199. * 投稿前质控流程
  200. ---
  201. ## 使用建议
  202. 为了提高核查准确性,建议用户提供尽可能完整的参考文献信息:
  203. * 对英文文献:题名、作者、期刊、年份、卷期页码、DOI、PMID/PMCID。
  204. * 对中文期刊论文:中文题名、中文作者、期刊全称、年份、卷期页码、DOI 或数据库来源。
  205. * 对中文学位论文:题名、作者、授予单位、学位类型、年份、数据库来源。
  206. * 对中文图书:书名、作者/编者、出版社、出版年份、ISBN、引用页码。
  207. * 对标准/政策/专利:标准号、文件号、专利号、发布机构、发布日期。
  208. ---
  209. ## 重要说明
  210. Reference Checker Skill 用于辅助参考文献核查,但不能完全替代人工审阅。
  211. 对于被标记为以下类型的参考文献,建议用户务必人工复核:
  212. * `Critical`
  213. * `Major`
  214. * `Manual check`
  215. 另外,知网、万方、维普等中文数据库可能存在访问权限限制。Skill 的作用是要求 AI 采用正确的检索路径、记录证据来源和不确定性;如果数据库无法访问,应明确标记为 `Manual check`,而不是臆造核查结果。
  216. 这个 Skill 的设计原则是:**宁可严格标记可疑问题,也不要把无法确认的参考文献默认为正确。**
  217. ---
  218. ## License
  219. MIT License.

Ratings and comments

Sign in to rate this skill.

Sign in

Free to use. If it’s helped, pass it on.