Skip to content
Back to search

talkyard

A community discussion platform: Brings together the main features from StackOverflow, Slack, Discourse, Reddit, and Disqus blog comments.

Safety scan

A static text scan, not a guarantee. Select the badge to see what was scanned and every finding.

Checked today
Badge for your README
findsafeskills safety rating

Markdown

[![findsafeskills safety rating](/api/listings/debiki--talkyard/badge.svg)](/listings/debiki--talkyard)

HTML

<a href="/listings/debiki--talkyard"><img src="/api/listings/debiki--talkyard/badge.svg" alt="findsafeskills safety rating" /></a>

Install

i

What was scanned

The files the safety scan read, as written by the repository's author and shown as plain text. Lines with a finding are marked.

README.md · README · 359 lines

View this file on GitHub (read at the repository's current version: the scan did not record which commit it read)

  1. <!--
  2. Old GitHub one-line description:
  3. - Discussion forums with Question & Answers and Team Chat features. Plus embedded comments for your blog.
  4. Current:
  5. - Open source StackOverflow, Slack, Discourse, Reddit, Disqus hybrid — for your online community.
  6. Other alternatives?:
  7. - Community software, brings together the best from StackOverflow + Slack + Reddit + Discourse.
  8. - Online community software. Find ideas and answers together, and pick the right things
  9. to do, to change society, or grow your startup.
  10. -->
  11. Talkyard
  12. =============================
  13. Forum software, with chat, and anonymous comments.
  14. - Thoughtful discussions. &thinsp;Insightful comments rise to the top.
  15. - Upvote ideas. &thinsp;Sort by votes.
  16. - Question-Answers. &thinsp;Discuss, select an answer.
  17. - Chat channels. &thinsp;Pretty basic features.
  18. - Blog comments. &thinsp;Listen to your readers.
  19. <!-- Community discussion platform, or Structured discussion platform? A/B test?
  20. Or "Structured discussions, for your community — Talkyard brings together ..." ?
  21. A structured discussions platform — brings together the main features from
  22. StackOverflow, Slack, Discourse, Reddit/HackerNews, and Disqus blog comments.
  23. -->
  24. <!--
  25. Create a place to talk,
  26. where your audience find answers to their questions, and discuss ideas.<br>
  27. Place it at `talkyard.Your-Website.org`.
  28. - **Solve problems** step by step, in traditional flat forum topics.
  29. - **Save time.** People find help "instantly", in Question & Answers topics.
  30. - **Crowdsource feedback and ideas.** Discuss, upvote, choose the right things to do.
  31. - **Collaborate,** in team chats.
  32. - **Talk with your blog readers,** in embedded comments.
  33. For your co-workers / customers /
  34. students / volunteers /
  35. contributors / users.
  36. You can use Slack and Mattermost etc for day to day teamwork,
  37. combined with Talkyard for the more important discussions
  38. that you want to find in a nice-to-read format, months and years later.
  39. Or use Talkyard for customer support, or for schools and students helping each other.
  40. -->
  41. How does it compare with other software? &thinsp;
  42. <a href="https://business.talkyard.io/compare/">Find out here</a>.<!--
  43. StackOverflow for Teams, Discourse, Slack, Facebook Groups, Disqus? -->
  44. **Self-Hosting:**&thinsp; See [talkyard-prod-one](https://github.com/debiki/talkyard-prod-one/tree/ty-prod-one-v1) <!-- Or use our hosting service: https://www.talkyard.io. -->
  45. **Demo:**&thinsp; https://insightful.demo.talkyard.io
  46. **Discussion forum:**&thinsp; https://forum.talkyard.io
  47. **Documentation:**&thinsp; https://docs.talkyard.io (incomplete)<!--
  48. Features: Copy a https://www.talkyard.io/compare/(something) page and show only Ty? -->
  49. **Development:**&thinsp; That's this repo! See: [docs/developing-talkyard.md](./docs/developing-talkyard.md)
  50. <!-- Immich has these links: https://github.com/immich-app/immich
  51. Documentation
  52. About
  53. Installation
  54. Roadmap
  55. Demo (although there's a Demo paragraph just below!)
  56. Features (although there's a Features list just below)
  57. Translations
  58. Contributing -->
  59. <!--
  60. For your students / volunteers / colleagues / customers / donors /
  61. open source users / city / community. -->
  62. <!--
  63. - **Improve your API docs**, by embedding comments at the end of each docs page, to make it easy for people to ask and tell you if something is unclear.
  64. -->
  65. <!-- (The staff configure the topic type just once, in a per category setting.) -->
  66. <!--
  67. Use Talkyard for your workplace, as a self building FAQ. Or for customer support.
  68. Or for your teachers and students, to help each other. Or your non-profit volunteers.
  69. Or an open source project and its users.
  70. We'd like to build a tool tha *people who change the world or their neighborhood* can use
  71. to solve problems and pick the right things to do. That's why we have
  72. find-solutions Question-Answers topics, and HackerNews & Reddit type topics
  73. where good ideas rise to the top.<! - — And you can use this tool,
  74. for your workplace and your colleagues & customers,
  75. or your non-profit and its volunteers,
  76. or an open source project and its users,
  77. or a school and its students, etc. -->
  78. <!--
  79. Talkyard (formerly EffectiveDiscussions) is discussion forum software, with chat and question-answers features.
  80. And embedded comments for static websites / blogs.
  81. Inspired by Discourse, Slack, StackOverflow, Reddit and Hacker News, Disqus. -->
  82. <!--
  83. ### Project size
  84. It's sort of possible for one person to understand all of Talkyard —
  85. as May 2021, `https://github.com/boyter/scc` says
  86. Talkyard is 140 000 (111 359 + 32 653 = 144 012) lines of code and comments
  87. (excluding blank lines). **and** that was with some other changes, different branch.
  88. Plus about 60 000 (59 425) lines test code.
  89. Server side code complexity: 5538, client side (a React.js web app): 8478.
  90. scc modules/ed-core/src modules/ty-dao-rdb/src/ client/app-* client/embedded-comments/ client/serviceworker/ client/*.ts app/ s/ Makefile to-talkyard/src/ gulpfile.js images/web/ty-lua/ images/web/*.conf images/app/Dockerfile.* images/rdb/
  91. scc tests/
  92. -->
  93. Features
  94. -----------
  95. ### Good comments rise to the top
  96. Find the interesting stuff, also in big discussions.
  97. <br/><br/>
  98. <table><tr><td>
  99. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/2017--estimate-unfamiliar-task.jpg" />
  100. </td></tr></table>
  101. <!-- SVG doesn't seem to work at GitHub:
  102. <svg width="100%" height="600" xmlns="www.w3.org">
  103. <rect x="0" y="0" width="100%" height="100%" fill="#222" stroke="none" stroke-width="2"/>
  104. <image y="3%" href="... something ..." width="100%" height="94%" />
  105. </svg> -->
  106. <!--
  107. ![Question and Answers](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/talkyard-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2018-08-19-question-ex.jpeg "Question-Answers")
  108. ![Question and Answers](/images/web/ty-media/for-docs/2018-08-19-question-ex.jpeg?raw=true "Question-Answers") -->
  109. <!--
  110. ![how-work-from-home-vpn-broken-borders](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/7477359/44306101-0041eb80-a388-11e8-92e8-b8d417c47139.jpg)
  111. -->
  112. ### Tags with values
  113. Create your own tags with **values**, list and sort by value.
  114. For example, a _priority_ tag: `tags:priority:desc>2 is:open`,
  115. here: https://forum.talkyard.io/-/search?q=tags:priority:desc%3E2+is:open
  116. <br/>
  117. <br/>
  118. ### Upvote ideas
  119. <table><tr><td>
  120. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/upvote-ideas--aqua-planet-mind-writing-b0a--blue-marks--dimmed.png" />
  121. </td></tr></table>
  122. <br/>
  123. <table><tr><td>
  124. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/2026-01--upvote-ideas-settings.png" />
  125. </td></tr></table>
  126. <br/>
  127. ### Anonymous comments
  128. So e.g. students can post embarassing questions. Or for anonymous feedback, etc.
  129. <table><tr><td>
  130. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/2026-01--anon-disc.png" />
  131. </td></tr></table>
  132. <br/>
  133. <table><tr><td>
  134. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/2026-01--anon-never-always-menu.png" />
  135. </td></tr></table>
  136. <br/>
  137. <table><tr><td>
  138. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/2026-01--anon-purpose-menu.png" />
  139. </td></tr></table>
  140. <br>
  141. ### Chat
  142. Notifications via email, as of now.
  143. <table><tr><td>
  144. <!-- /images/web/ty-media/for-docs/2017-09-12-chat-ex.jpeg -->
  145. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2017-09-12-chat-ex.jpeg" alt="A chat channel"/>
  146. </td></tr></table>
  147. <br>
  148. <!--
  149. ![ed-e2e-chat-owen-maria](https://cloud.githubusercontent.com/assets/7477359/19674424/608c49aa-9a88-11e6-8ccd-c2e7ceebd0c2.jpg)
  150. -->
  151. <!--
  152. ![Q&A about how to wake up on time](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/7477359/39368115-0549fad0-4a39-11e8-9bba-703d595d2b96.jpg)
  153. -->
  154. <!--
  155. Hacker News / Reddit style discussion:
  156. ![ed-discussion-semantics-of-upvote-2013](https://cloud.githubusercontent.com/assets/7477359/19650769/bea906aa-9a0a-11e6-8ea2-9ad771981f46.jpg)
  157. -->
  158. <!--
  159. **Admin-getting-started guide:**
  160. ![ed-admin-intro-guide](https://cloud.githubusercontent.com/assets/7477359/19679591/99a12098-9aa2-11e6-8b65-705c2548cbea.jpg)
  161. <br>
  162. -->
  163. ### Users online
  164. ![ed-online-users](https://cloud.githubusercontent.com/assets/7477359/19680424/f0353f86-9aa5-11e6-84d9-94d46f228b93.jpg)
  165. <br>
  166. ### Avoid mistakes
  167. There's a _Disagree_ button. <!-- See if others disagree with something. so you can avoid following the wrong advice. -->
  168. <table><tr><td>
  169. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/penguins-can-fly.jpg"/>
  170. </td></tr></table>
  171. <!--
  172. ![Avoid mistakes](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/penguins-can-fly.jpg)
  173. ![Avoid mistakes](https://tyw-49f8.kxcdn.com/-/u/e7ef490a72/2/m/nu/zecljq7vwtuyxqfabsjwqzg6bfmyvr.jpg) -->
  174. <br>
  175. ### Big discussions
  176. **Find new replies** by clicking **Recent** in the sidebar,
  177. when you return to a discussion a day later.
  178. <!--
  179. (But at GitHub, Reddit, HackerNews, you need to skim the whole discussion
  180. from top to bottom to see if anything new has appeared.) -->
  181. <table><tr><td>
  182. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/talkyard-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2019-08-10-recent-replies-ex-anon-arw.jpg" />
  183. </td></tr></table>
  184. <!--
  185. ![Recent replies](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/talkyard-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2019-08-10-recent-replies-ex-anon-arw.jpg "Recent replies")
  186. -->
  187. **Jump to the parent comment** and back:
  188. <!-- Doesn't work:
  189. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/jump-and-save-time.mp4
  190. <video width="500" data-height="260"
  191. src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/jump-and-save-time.mp4"></video>
  192. But uploading via GitHub's user interface works: (url must be in its own paragraph) -->
  193. https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/fc1b34d7-75e3-4baf-95e1-8de364cdfdf2
  194. <br/>
  195. ### Topic list
  196. <!--
  197. ![topic-list-borders](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/7477359/44306130-a3930080-a388-11e8-9cbc-e569f5ddb7a1.jpg)
  198. the old demo forum looks better? so use instead. -->
  199. ![Topics list](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/ty-media/refs/heads/p/m/9/for-docs/2019-08-10-idea-topics-list-ex.jpg "Topics list")
  200. <!--
  201. ![ideas-topics](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/talkyard-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2019-08-10-idea-topics-list-ex.jpg "Topics list")
  202. -->
  203. <!--
  204. ![ideas-topics](/images/web/ty-media/for-docs/2019-08-10-idea-topics-list-ex.jpg?raw=true "Topics list")
  205. ![ed-demo-forum-index](https://cloud.githubusercontent.com/assets/7477359/19650764/bb3a1450-9a0a-11e6-884d-d23c93476db3.jpg) -->
  206. <br>
  207. ### Blog comments
  208. Like Disqus — but no ads, no tracking. Configure in the Admin Area | Settings | Embedded Comments. Read more here: https://blog-comments.talkyard.io
  209. <!--
  210. There's a Disqus importer — talk with us [in the forum](https://www.talkyard.io/forum/) if you want to migrate from Disqus to Talkyard.
  211. -->
  212. <table><tr><td>
  213. <img src="https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/talkyard-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2019-02-21-blog-comments-ex-anon.jpg" />
  214. </td></tr></table>
  215. <!--
  216. ![blog comments](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/talkyard-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2019-02-21-blog-comments-ex-anon.jpg "Blog comments")
  217. ![blog comments](/images/web/ty-media/for-docs/2019-02-21-blog-comments-ex-anon.jpg?raw=true "Blog comments")
  218. -->
  219. <br>
  220. <!-- Now implemented, see Anonymous Comments above.
  221. ### Embarrassing questions, creative ideas:
  222. Let your students ask anonymous questions. Maybe they feel ashamed for not knowing?
  223. — Or let your co-workers submit ideas and feedback, anonymously.
  224. Maybe they feel worried their ideas has crossed the border from Creative to Crazy?
  225. They can un-anonymize themselves later if they want to (per page).
  226. (Anonymous posting first needs to be enabled, by admins.
  227. Here you can read more: https://www.talkyard.io/-239/is-there-anonymous-messages-support-for-the-full-talkyard )
  228. Anonymous posts has been implemented, but not code reviewed and merged.
  229. ![Post anonymously](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/debiki/talkyard-media/bf78d26ec3f4da976d9c694a660d40b718d86043/for-docs/2019-08-10-editor-post-anonymously-ex-arw.jpg "Post anonymously")
  230. -->
  231. Old Code
  232. -----------------------------
  233. Old code from before January 2015 is available here:
  234. https://github.com/debiki/debiki-server-old.
  235. That repo, squashed, is in this repo.
  236. License
  237. -----------------------------
  238. Copyright (c) 2010-2026 Kaj Magnus Lindberg and contributors.
  239. Talkyard is licensed under AGPLv3 or later, see LICENSE.txt.
  240. <!-- Later, add this, but first ask someone if the wording is ok:
  241. Starting on 2032-01-01, this specific version of Talkyard (see ./version.txt)
  242. is also licensed under GPLv2 or later. That is, AGPLv3+ until year 2032, thereafter
  243. dual licensed under AGPLv3+ and GPLv2+.
  244. Note:
  245. - We try to bump the above GPLv2 date each year, so it's 6–7 years in the future.
  246. - After the above GPLv2+ date, you can *not* redistribute Talkyard under GPLv2
  247. — Talkyard includes Apache2 software and Apache2 is incompatible with GPLv2.
  248. You can, however, after the GPLv2+ date, redistribute Talkyard under GPLv3+.
  249. -->
  250. This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
  251. but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
  252. MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the
  253. above-mentioned licence texts for more details.

Ratings and comments

Sign in to rate this skill.

Sign in

Free to use. If it’s helped, pass it on.